Mar 19th, 2007
The Jim Halpert Effect
"Tragedy is bad things happening to good people. Comedy is bad things happening to bad people." - Aristotle’s Poetics
Jim Halpert is that loveable everyman from The Office (US). He has two hot girls chasing after him, he has to deal with idiots at work, and most importantly, he always turns to the camera and makes goofy faces. The faces says, "Oh my God, he’s such an idiot, I can’t believe he just did that." It let’s the audience know that they’re in on the joke. It lets them feel superior, and a lot of comedy is about feeling superior - watching idiots do something stupid & laughing at them. It’s what Seinfeld did, Alex Reiger did it in Taxi, however subtly. Seinfeld chose his friend, though - he loved their zaniness. Jim Halpert, like Alex Reiger use the job as an excuse to keep them around these entertaining simpletons.
When the Volkswagen "Zero Ego Emmissions" commercials came out, I said to myself, "they just gave away the keys to the castle. They just said explicitly what’s implicit in every VW ad." But nobody else seemed to catch on, at least, nobody I talked to said something like that.
Nearly every VW ad says "We’re not stuck up, we’re just better than everyone else." What better message for a "German Engineered" car that’s not that German Engineered car to send? You’re better than those that can’t afford German Engineering, and you’re better than those that go for the obvious choice because of their own insecurities.
The Mac vs. PC ads are iconic & by the 2nd paragraph you knew I was going there. Something about the Mac guy just makes me want to smack him around, though. His smug superiority & PC’s sincere attempts at coolness just doesn’t do it for me. If PC was like Dwight and almost malicious in his stupidity I might buy it, but PC is just PC. Mac’s exasperation at PC’s shenanigans quite obviously convey a sense of superiority. It’s not even hidden here, it’s palpable.
If you don’t think Mac is Jim Halpert, take a close look at Mac in the Mac vs. PC Vista ad. Just as PC’s personal bodyguard says "You are coming to a sad realization, cancel or allow?" Mac looks off and makes a face. In fact, he spends much of the commercial making funny faces.
Look at the Zero Ego Emmissions ad again, it happens at least 3 times. They make a face while staring directly at the people who are acting crazy, the female passenger looks at us/the driver and makes a face, and then they shrug as they toss out their megaphone.
This we’re better than you attitude isn’t just the purview of shiny toys for metrosexuals with too much money on their hands, the "we get it, we’re with you, this is stupid" attitude has been around for a while.
I’m not sure who did it first, but I first became aware of the general technique of "letting the audience know you’re in on the joke " during the Sprite "Image is nothing / Obey your Thirst" and "Make 7-Up Yours" campaigns. These were ads that said "Yeah, advertising is stupid, we get it too. Wink, wink, nudge, nudge. See, we’re one of you." These didn’t have a Jim Halpert-esque character in them, but like the Peter Stormare "Unpimp Your Auto" VW ads, they’re pure camp and acknowledge that on some level, all ads are artificial.
The Jim Halpert is all over this early Washington Mutual ad (one of the first with "The Banker’s Pen"), and indeed all the WaMu ads. The Geico Caveman is a master at it, but does it more as indignation at the stupidity of those around him. In a clever twist, the Caveman is superior to the people whose product you’re being sold, disarming the Geico folks and making them seem more approachable for their fallibility. This hearkens back to the "Make 7-Up Yours" ads where we’re being told that ads are stupid. Even though it’s a Geico representative that’s being an idiot, he really represents all the old stodgy insurance firms.
Let’s review the ingredients for a Jim Halpert.
1. You have to have a character the audience will identify with.
2. He (or she) has to be surrounded by idiots.
3. He has to react to the idiots. Preferrably by looking aside, possibly even straight at the camera, and making a face.
4. Optional. For "cleverness" brownie points, make the people selling your product the idiots.
It’s a really fun way to make ads - you can have a lot of fun inventing all sorts of idiots, and by putting someone in the ad who realizes they’re idiots, you can make your customers feel superior to everyone else.